Ask Slashdot: Have AI Coding Tools Killed the Joy of Programming?

Longtime Slashdot reader DaPhil writes: I taught myself to code at 12 years old in the 90s and I’ve always liked the back-and-forth with the runtime to achieve the right result. I recently got back from other roles to code again, and when starting a new project last year, I decided to give the new “AI assistants” a go.

My initial surprise at the quality and the speed you can achieve when using ChatGPT and/or Copilot when coding turned sour over the months, as I realized that all the joy I felt about trying to get the result I want — slowly improving my code by (slowly) thinking, checking the results against the runtime, and finally achieving success — is, well, gone. What I do now is type English sentences in increasingly desperate attempts to get ChatGPT to output what I want (or provide snippets to Copilot to get the right autocompletion), which — as they are pretty much black boxes — is frustrating and non-linear: it either “just works,” or it doesn’t. There is no measure of progress. In a way, having Copilot in the IDE was even worse, since it often disrupts my thinking when suggesting completions.

I’ve since disabled Copilot. Interestingly, I myself now feel somehow “disabled” without it in the IDE; however, the abstention has given me back the ability to sit back and think, and through that, the joy of programming. Still, it feels like I’m now somehow an ex-drug addict always on the verge of a relapse. I was wondering if any of you felt the same, or if I’m just… old.

Read more of this story at Slashdot. Read More

Leave a Comment

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *